I will admit that when charcoal-based products started flooding the market a few years ago, I thought it was just another marketing gimmick. Black-colored face washes, scrubs, shampoos… every brand seemed to have jumped on the charcoal bandwagon. But over time, curiosity got the better of me, and I ended up trying a few. And since then, I have not only tested some of these products myself but also spent a lot of time going through forums, Reddit threads, and reviews to separate the good stuff from the overhyped ones. So, is charcoal grooming just a trend, or does it really work? Let me break it down.
What’s the Big Deal with Charcoal Anyway?
Charcoal in grooming is mostly marketed as activated charcoal, which is supposed to have the power to absorb dirt, excess oil, and impurities from your skin and scalp. The idea is simple: tiny charcoal particles can trap toxins and deep-clean more effectively than your average cleanser. Sounds good, right? But here’s what I’ve noticed just having charcoal in the ingredient list doesn’t guarantee a great product. The other ingredients, the formulation, and how your skin or hair reacts to it matter much more.
My Experience: – What Worked and What Didn’t
1. Beardo Activated Charcoal Face Wash
This was one of the first charcoal face washes I tried. What I liked about it is that it actually left my skin feeling clean without making it dry and stretchy (something that happens with a lot of face washes claiming to remove oil). The texture is smooth, and the charcoal content doesn’t feel abrasive. On sweaty days or after workouts, this one has become my go-to. It’s not magic—you still need to moisturise—but it does its job.
2. Bombay Shaving Company Charcoal Face Scrub
I bought this after seeing tons of positive reviews online, and honestly, it deserves the hype. The scrub granules are gentle, not the harsh, sandpaper-like type that damages your skin. What I noticed was it helped clear out blackheads around my nose better than some regular walnut scrubs I’ve used before. On Reddit India threads, I also found people mentioning it works well for combination skin types without causing breakouts.
3. The Man Company Charcoal Peel-Off Mask
I had high hopes for this, but it turned out to be more of a pain than a benefit. Sure, it pulls out some gunk, but it also tugs on facial hair and leaves my skin red. I came across quite a few Quora answers where people said the same—that it looks satisfying to peel off, but doesn’t do much for actual skin health. One guy even joked that the only thing it peels off effectively is patience!
4. WOW Skin Science Charcoal Shampoo
I tried this one during a phase when I was dealing with greasy scalp issues. It smells fresh and gives a cooling feel, and it does clean well after a hot, sweaty day. But the flip side is—it can feel a bit too drying if used frequently. From product reviews and Reddit feedback, it seems I’m not alone; many suggested pairing it with a good conditioner to avoid dryness.
5. Ustraa Charcoal Deodorizing Soap
I bought this on a whim during an online sale. It looks cool, but performance-wise, it’s just a regular soap with an overpowering fragrance. There was no noticeable difference in sweat control or odor management compared to any standard soap. And reviews on Quora and Amazon India reflected the same experience—style over substance.
What People Say Online
After combing through dozens of threads and review sections, here’s the general mood I found:
Charcoal face washes and scrubs get good marks if they are from reliable brands. People find them useful for oily skin, especially in Indian humidity. Charcoal shampoos are seen as a good occasional cleanser, not for daily use unless you have very oily hair. Peel-off masks with charcoal are where most disappointments lie. They rarely deliver on their promises beyond superficial blackhead removal. Charcoal soaps and body washes are mostly gimmicky, with most users saying the same thing—nice to look at, average performance.
A lot of guys on Reddit India also pointed out that just because it’s black and labeled charcoal doesn’t mean it’s more powerful than a well-formulated regular cleanser.
Charcoal Products That Are Actually Worth It
If you want to try charcoal grooming without falling for the gimmick, here are some options that I think (and the community seems to agree) actually deliver:
Beardo Activated Charcoal Face Wash:– As I said earlier, reliable for oily/combination skin.
Bombay Shaving Company Charcoal Face Scrub: – Gentle, effective, and feels premium for the price.
WOW Skin Science Charcoal Shampoo: – Good once or twice a week if you have oily hair.
Garnier Men Acno Fight Charcoal Face Wash: – A budget-friendly option that’s popular on Amazon with solid reviews.
Products You Can Skip
The Man Company Charcoal Peel-Off Mask: – Just not worth the hassle, especially if you have facial hair.
Ustraa Charcoal Soap: – Cool packaging, but that’s about it.
Random no-brand charcoal soaps or body washes: – Most are just basic soaps dyed black.
So my verdict after all this testing and researching? Charcoal-based grooming products can be effective, but you need to choose wisely. It’s not the charcoal itself that’s magic it’s the whole product formulation that matters. There are some genuinely good face washes and scrubs out there that contain charcoal and do help with oily skin and clogged pores. But at the same time, a lot of charcoal products are just cashing in on the trend and won’t do much more than a regular, cheaper alternative.
Personally, I’ll keep using my Beardo face wash and Bombay Shaving Company scrub. They suit my skin, and they actually work. But I’ll pass on the gimmicky stuff like peel-off masks and fancy soaps.
by
Honestly I always thought charcoal products were a city boy fad. But I finally tried a charcoal face wash from a local brand, and it totally dried my skin out. That Beardo one you mentioned does it really help with oil control without making your face feel like a desert? I’ve got one of those oily but somehow still dry faces.
That skin type sounds familiar—mine does the same, especially in winter. The Beardo one was a pleasant surprise for me because it managed to clean off sweat and grime without that tight, flaky feeling afterward. I still use a basic moisturiser afterward, but it didn’t strip my skin the way some others did. If you do try it, maybe start with a smaller bottle and see how your skin reacts.
This post was very helpful for someone like me who shops for the men in my family. My younger brother is obsessed with anything that looks cool, which is why our bathroom has 3 half-used charcoal soaps. Do you think I should just replace them with a good face wash instead?
Haha sounds like your brother and I were in the same phase once. Honestly, yes swapping out the flashy soap bars for a decent face wash will probably do more good than harm. Maybe keep one charcoal soap for the post-gym refresh vibe, but for everyday use, something like the Beardo face wash is more reliable. He will thank you later even if he won’t admit it!
I’m glad someone finally said that about peel-off masks. Those things are painful, and I don’t know why I convinced myself they’d do anything for my skin. Do you think clay masks are better for oily skin, like multani mitti types? Or are those just old-school now?
Yeah those peel-off masks are lowkey a trap more drama than results. I actually still respect good clay masks, especially multani mitti. They don’t look fancy, but they’re great for pulling out oil and calming breakouts. I usually do one on weekends when I have been out in the dust or sun a lot. Just don’t overdo it or leave them on too long, or they can dry you out too.
Why does nobody talk about the smell of these products? Some of these charcoal face washes smell like burnt rubber, bro. The Bombay Shaving one was okay, but I had to ditch a different brand just ’cause it made me feel like I was washing with tire polish.
😂 Bro I know exactly what you are talking about some of them smell like you are prepping for a pit stop at an F1 race. The Bombay Shaving one actually smells mild and kind of herbal, which is why I stuck with it. Definitely one of the better ones on the nose. Smell is underrated in these reviews, and it shouldn’t be!
You said exactly what I always suspected: that black doesn’t mean better. I bought one of those charcoal soaps thinking it would somehow deep clean me into a new person, but it didn’t even last long. Are there any soaps that are actually functional for guys who sweat a lot?
Haha I felt the same when I bought that Ustraa soap looked badass, felt basic. For sweating, I actually recommend going with something like Nivea Active Clean or Pears with mint, they are not charcoal, but they do the job well and feel refreshing. Charcoal just isn’t the game-changer for odor or sweat that it’s hyped up to be.
Charcoal shampoo was the only thing that helped during peak summer when my scalp felt like a frying pan, but yeah, using it too often made my hair feel straw-like. Did you try mixing it with a conditioner, or do you use it just solo? I’m still hunting for the right combo.
Totally get what you mean! During sweaty seasons that shampoo’s a godsend but I did feel it was overkill more than twice a week. I actually started alternating it with a mild aloe-based conditioner (nothing fancy, even a Himalaya one works) and that helped stop the dryness. You might want to experiment with frequency more than switching products.
Do you think these charcoal products would work for women with oily skin too, or is it all tailored to men’s skin specifically?
Honestly, most of these products are just branded for men with a stronger scent and darker packaging but the actual ingredients can work for anyone. If you don’t mind a more woody smell, the Beardo face wash or Bombay scrub should work just fine on oily skin. Or you can look for gender-neutral or milder versions if that’s more your vibe.